Home › Business Services › Insurance broker
The 10 Best Insurance Brokers in Philadelphia (2026)
Philadelphia residents rely on a mix of neighborhood agents and larger brokerages for auto, home and business coverage, so we compiled the city’s top-rated options based on real customer feedback. This list is built from Google reviews and uses a Bayesian weighting to balance pure star ratings with review volume, helping prevent newer shops with a handful of perfect scores from outranking established firms. Updated for 2026, the ranking reflects the current Google ratings landscape across Philadelphia and nearby addresses, so you can narrow your search to highly rated local insurance professionals backed by broad reviewer consensus.
This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.
Are you a insurance broker in Philadelphia?
People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.
✓ Live immediately · ✓ One-time payment · ✓ No subscription
10 of 10 spots still available
Starlight Agency LLC
Starlight Agency LLC tops our list thanks to its perfect 5.0 Google rating combined with 200 reviews, giving it the strongest Bayes-weighted score among local agencies. Listed as an Insurance agency and located on Bustleton Avenue in Philadelphia, its combination of rating and review volume pushes it above other highly rated competitors. That balance of excellent score and sizable reviewer sample is what earned Starlight the number one spot in our 2026 ranking.
The full ranking
Mars Tag & Insurance Agency
Mars Tag & Insurance Agency is shown with a 5.0 rating based on 170 reviews and is categorized as an Insurance agency in Philadelphia. The business appears on West Girard Avenue within the city.
170 reviews
Inco Insurance Services
Inco Insurance Services has a 5.0 rating from 144 reviewers and is listed as an Insurance agency in Philadelphia. Its address on East York Street places it in the city’s eastside corridor.
144 reviews
Main Line Risk Management
Main Line Risk Management posts a 5.0 rating with 131 reviews and is identified as an Insurance agency in Philadelphia at City Ave. The listing reflects strong reviewer scores despite a smaller number of ratings than some peers.
131 reviews
Maxie Insurance LLC ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Maxie Insurance LLC ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ shows a 4.9 rating across 837 reviews and is categorized as an Auto insurance agency in Philadelphia. Its high review count gives it significant weight in overall rankings.
837 reviews
Nationwide Insurance: Ott & Associates Inc.
Nationwide Insurance: Ott & Associates Inc. carries a 4.9 rating from 554 reviewers and is listed as an Insurance agency in Philadelphia on Cottman Avenue. The large review base boosts its credibility in our Bayes-weighted method.
554 reviews
Mackley Insurance, Inc.
Mackley Insurance, Inc. is rated 4.9 from 170 reviews and is recorded as an Insurance agency in Blue Bell, PA. This entry is one of the few on the list located outside Philadelphia proper.
170 reviews
Troast-Singley & Miller Insurance Agency
Troast-Singley & Miller Insurance Agency holds a 4.9 rating with 162 Google reviews and is listed as an Insurance agency in Philadelphia on South 18th Street. The combination of solid scores and steady reviewer counts places it among the top ten.
162 reviews
Shayna Carnevale at Comparion Insurance Agency
Shayna Carnevale at Comparion Insurance Agency posts a 4.9 rating from 146 reviewers and is classified as an Insurance agent in Philadelphia at 100 E Penn Square. Its Center City address appears on City Hall’s square.
146 reviews
Insurephilly.com
Insurephilly.com carries a 4.9 rating based on 90 reviews and is listed as an Insurance agency in Philadelphia at Academy Road. It rounds out the top ten with a strong average and a moderate review total.
90 reviews
Frequently asked questions
How should I choose an insurance broker in Philadelphia?
Look for a broker with options from multiple carriers, clear explanations of coverage, and solid reviewer feedback. Compare quotes, check recent customer reviews, and confirm the agent is licensed in Pennsylvania before making a decision.
What should I check before hiring an insurance broker?
Verify the broker’s licensing and any professional credentials, ask about the specific coverages and exclusions, and get written quotes. Also request references or recent client reviews to understand service responsiveness and claims support.
How much do brokers typically charge for their services?
Many insurance brokers are paid by the insurer through commissions and may not charge separate fees, but practices vary. Ask upfront about any broker fees, how they’re compensated, and whether they’ll shop multiple carriers on your behalf.
How was this ranking of Philadelphia insurance brokers created?
This list was generated from Google review data and uses a Bayesian-weighted score that combines average ratings with review counts to favor businesses with both high scores and substantial reviewer samples. The data set was reviewed and updated for 2026 to reflect current public ratings.